Is it possible to bake cookies in a toaster oven?

Although baking cookies in a full-sized oven is the most usual approach, there are various ways to prepare these delectable sweets. Consider utilizing a toaster oven if you live in a small apartment or simply don’t want to heat up your entire kitchen.

In a toaster oven, you can bake cookies just like you would in a regular oven. The batch size, temperature control, and some of the accessories (such as baking sheets) are the only variations between the two.

You’ll need to thoroughly understand the intricacies that your toaster oven brings to the table before you can make outstanding toaster oven-baked cookies. Let’s get started!

Using a Toaster Oven to Bake Cookies

Baking in a toaster oven is a lot like baking in a regular oven. You will, however, most likely need to use a smaller baking sheet / container and change the temperature settings.

As you can see, the components and dough are prepared in a same manner. However, there are a few things you must do with toaster ovens that you would not need to do for a standard oven.

For example, if you’re baking cookies in your toaster oven for the first time (or if it’s been a while), you’ll want to check the temperature.

Examine the Temperature

Make sure you know how to set the temperature on your toaster oven before you start laying out the cookie dough.

Most toaster ovens offer a “bake” function that allows you to specify the temperature you want to bake at, as well as a timer. Keep in mind that some characteristics may appear to be quite different from those on a standard oven.

Once you’ve selected your temperature settings, it’s critical to test them to ensure that the temperature you set corresponds to the actual temperature it achieves. Oven thermometers are an excellent measuring tool for this.

The reason for this is because toaster ovens don’t always heat up to the temperature that they’re set to. As a result, you’ll want to know whether there’s a difference in the true temperature so you can correct it and get the appropriate temperature for your recipe.

Assemble your tools

Before you start making the dough, double-check that you have all of the tools you’ll need to bake safely and effectively in your toaster oven.

Frequently, the same utensils that you would use to bake in a traditional oven will also function in a toaster oven. However, there are a few goods that you may require in smaller quantities.

  1. Baking pan

You’ll want to double-check that you have the right-sized baking sheet on hand. You could already have a pan or sheet from your toaster oven. If you do, congratulations; you should be fine.

If you need a sheet to accommodate your toaster oven, on the other hand, be sure you obtain the proper size – especially if you’re ordering online.

Look up the business that makes your toaster oven and check whether they sell accessories specifically for the model you own to avoid making a mistake.

  1. Baking Mat (Silicone)

In a conventional oven, silicone baking mats can be used. If not, they are exactly what their name implies: a silicone baking mat.

Of course, you’ll need a smaller oven for a toaster oven. That’s why we’re bringing it up now.

Furthermore, these silicone mats are ideal for baking in a toaster oven because they:

Remove the burden of washing a soiled pan.

Are they non-stick?

Are they reusable?

You will save money on parchment paper.

  1. Puller for the Toaster Rack

One of the benefits of utilizing a larger oven for baking is that the extra space allows you to reach inside and shift dishes or pull out racks without risking burning yourself.

The narrower entrance and smaller interior of a toaster oven make removing items a little riskier.

Use a toaster rack puller instead of risking a burn. It reduces the need to reach straight into the hot oven, and it may also be handy in a regular oven. Rack pullers are also reasonably priced and simple to use.

  1. Oven Liner for Toaster

It’s also a good idea to have a toaster oven liner on hand. Oven liners are thick metal sheets that go on the bottom of your toaster oven to collect any crumbs or oil that fall through the cooking racks while the oven is heating up food.

It is critical that you do not get a thin oven liner if you decide to purchase one of them. You want the liner to be able to survive being heated at high temperatures over and over again. A thin liner may curl, crack, or even start smoking if used incorrectly.

Purchasing an oven liner saves time and money by preventing you from having to replace a fragile, thin liner.

  1. a pair of oven mitts

Let’s face it, let’s be honest. Toaster ovens don’t require special little oven gloves (although that could be kind of cute). For a toaster oven, you can use your usual oven mitts.

However, I wanted to make this point because I don’t want you to get burned. Because toaster ovens are smaller than ovens, you run the danger of burning yourself if you contact the rack or edges.

As a result, use sturdy oven mitts that completely cover your hands to safeguard your hands.

Make a Cookie Test

It’s time to bake a test cookie after you’ve gathered all of your supplies and found out how to use your toaster oven’s temperature settings.

This is especially critical if your toaster oven has temperature options like “cookies” that aren’t specific. Before you create a complete batch, be sure you know exactly how one cookie will turn out.

If the single test cookie turns out well, you should make a few more to see if your toaster oven has any hot or cold regions.

After your toaster oven has passed the test, you can bake as many cookies as you like (or as many as you can fit!).

Which Cookies Should I Make First?

Not sure which cookies to try first with your toaster oven? Here are some suggestions:

Chocolate Chip Cookies are a classic.

Chocolate chip cookies are a classic that never goes out of style. Why go any further than you have to when you’re already attempting something new by baking them in a toaster oven?

Cookies with Brown Butter and Bourbon Spice

Make some Brown Butter Bourbon Spice Cookies if you want to push yourself. These are Fall cookies, but they’re delicious all year.

A recipe (along with some delicious images) may be found here.

Cookies with Vegan Chocolate Chips

You can try this vegan chocolate chip cookie recipe from if you want to attempt a vegan variation.

A Few Pointers to Get You Started

Here’s a quick rundown of the tips at the beginning of the post. If you follow these guidelines, you’ll be baking delicious cookies in no time!

Make sure you know how to use your toaster oven’s temperature and timer.

Check with an oven thermometer to see if your toaster oven reaches the desired temperature.

BEFORE you start baking in your toaster oven, gather all of the culinary equipment you’ll need.

Before you create a complete batch, test your new equipment and toaster oven with a test cookie.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here